What Civilization Does Not Need

The other day I mentioned something about teachers being job creators and firefighters being a sign of civilization; then Mitt Romney gaffingly disagreed. While right wing commentators puff themselves up with synthetic outrage over the notion of class warfare, it is difficult to see conservative intentions to dismantle the social infrastructure as anything but. The American public school system made the triumphs of the 20th Century possible because it nurtures and supports the middle class; it is one of the institutions that makes the American Dream attainable. There will always be private education, just as there has been back to Socrates and before. The wealthy will be able to send their children to exclusive academies and hire the finest tutors, and there is nothing wrong with this; it is one of the privileges of wealth.

The problem is that private education cannot replace public education any more than a private security firm can replace a police force; this is not to say that these things cannot be done but that the results would be quickly disastrous. As it is, cutbacks to social programs are already having tragic results; it could be argued that any number of recent horrific incidents are a result of a lack of resources for people on the edge. Private schools aren’t legally obligated to accept children with disabilities or emotional problems, nor are they equipped to deal with children from extremely dysfunctional families. Again, there is nothing wrong with this, but if the public school system is largely replaced by under-regulated charter schools and private academies there will be terrible consequences, and things are already bad.

The Bush Cabal, with the lockstep agreement of Republicans and very little help from Democrats, were able to erase a budgetary surplus, replace it with a deficit, and enacted fiscal policies that obliterated %40 of middle class American’s wealth while making themselves even wealthier. Republican apologists without shame blame the recession on minority families rather than policies of deregulation and manipulation of the tax code, which is where it squarely rests (No citation needed for stating the obvious). The very real economic burden of these terrible decisions is now falling on the most vulnerable and voiceless members of our society. Which means that further cutting of the funding for public education and emergency services is a monstrous idea.

The money the middle and lower classes lost was not burned in a furnace or buried by pirates; it rests comfortably in the coffers of corporations. These corporations, or ‘people’, as Mr Romney thinks of them, have done very well while the rest of us have not; but then, nobody wants to hear sob stories about poor people, even when they are us. The money for the rebuilding of our infrastructure, the care of our sick and elderly loved ones, and the education of our children is clutched in the inhuman hands of these entities, and yet the media mouthpieces of these creatures tells us that it is the greedy teachers and firefighters who are responsible for the economic wasteland before us. So ask yourself, what does civilization need? Teachers and firefighters, or corporate ‘people’. The answer says everything about who you are.

4 Responses to “What Civilization Does Not Need”

  1. I had the most inane argument with an uncompassionate person last week over the topic of dissolving the public education system. My suggestion that business couldn’t possibly regulate itself in the areas of special circumstances and impoverished school districts was constantly passed over. He had no rebuttal so he chose to avoid it.

    • And that’s exactly the point- there is no ‘profitable’ way to educate certain populations of students. It’s partly a case of having a hammer and seeing every problem as a nail, and partly a case of an inability to comprehend that everyone else isn’t just like them. This isn’t to say that there aren’t inefficiencies and incompetence to be found; but the same can be found at JP Morgan.

  2. The Prof Says:

    This is what happens when you lose the moderates. With all due respect to any die-hard Republicans out there who read this, the GOP has gone insane and seem prepared to drive the country off a cliff to 1.) get rid of Obama (this desire supersedes all else;) and 2.) to institute their right-wing wet dream social engineering agenda. Can’t wait until Atlas Shrugged is required reading for all public school kids–and I’m guessing when it is the teachers will be forbidden from engaging it in any way.

    Also–you shaved your head? O’ sadness. We miss you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: